Liquidation Preference in Venture Capital Deals

What is Liquidation Preference?

A Liquidation Preference provision sets out the level of priority that an investors’ shares receive for the purpose of recovering their initial investment (or a multiple thereof) upon trigger of a liquidation event. A liquidation event typically includes winding up, sale of substantial assets of a company, change of control, merger, acquisition, reorganization and other corporate transactions, among others.

How Liquidation Preference Helps an Investor?

1Recovery of InitialA liquidation preference allows the investors to recover at least their initial investment in a company.
2Multiple on the Initial InvestmentA liquidation preference provision also allows the investors to earn a multiple on their initial investment, i.e., instead of 1x, investors may seek 2x or more, if so agreed.
3Distribution in order of seniorityA liquidation preference clause allows the distribution of the proceeds to be in an order of priority on the basis of the series of securities held by the investors.

.

Types and Mechanics of Liquidation Preference

Types of Liquidation Preference

Type of LPParticulars
Non-participating Liquidation Preference
1xAllows the investors to recover only their initial investment in the company.
1x or pro-rata, whichever is higher* (single dip)Allows the investors to recover their initial investment or entitles them to the proceeds from the liquidation event, basis their pro-rata shareholding in the company (on an as-if converted basis), whichever is higher.
Participating Liquidation Preference
1x (double-dip)Allows the investor to recover their initial investment (or a multiple thereof) in addition to a right to participate in the remaining proceeds basis their pro-rata shareholding in the company.

*Note:The multiple on the liquidation preference may be more than 1x and the amount of distribution of the liquidation preference shall be determined basis such a multiple.

Let us understand the mechanism of different types of liquidation preference through the below illustration:

Investment AmountINR 10cr
Percentage shareholding in the Company10%

.

Scenario 1: Non-participating liquidation preference

1x or pro rata, whichever is higher

Total Liquidation proceeds*Investors’ liquidation entitlement (2x)Investors’ liquidation entitlement (pro-rata)Actual entitlement
INR 20crINR 10crINR 2crINR 10cr.
INR 200crINR 10crINR 20crINR 20cr.

*Note: The total liquidation proceeds are the total proceeds from a liquidation event which are subject to distribution between the shareholders.

2x or pro rata, whichever is higher

Total Liquidation proceeds*Investors’ liquidation entitlement (2x)Investors’ liquidation entitlement (pro-rata)Actual entitlement
INR 20crINR 20crINR 2crINR 20cr.
INR 400crINR 20crINR 40crINR 40cr.

.

This form of liquidation preference is most desirable as, while it allows the investors to recover their initial investment, it also enables them to take advantage of the upside in case the larger proceeds are accumulated from a liquidation event.

It is however, not recommend signing up for a multiple on the investment amount.

Scenario 2: 1x (participating liquidation preference)

Total Liquidation proceeds*Investors’ liquidation entitlement (1x)Investors’ liquidation entitlement (pro-rata)Actual Entitlement
INR 20crINR 10crINR 2crINR 12cr
INR 500crINR 10crINR 50crINR 60cr.

.

While this may seem like a desirable form of liquidation preference, in the event the structure of a liquidation is not pari passu, i.e., in case the liquidation clause provides for a seniority, this may lead to disadvantage to the holders of equity shares (in most cases, the founders).

Conclusion

In conclusion, while liquidation preference is a crucial right for the investors, it is important for the founders to be mindful about the construct of this provision.

Early stage founders are recommended to consider the 1x non-participating liquidation preference, preferably provided in Scenario 1. Excessive or stringent liquidation preferences can deter future investment rounds and put the founders at risk of reduced share in the liquidation proceeds.

About the Author
Treelife

Treelife provides legal and financial support to startups, small business, companies and entrepreneurs with access to a team of professionals.

We Are Problem Solvers. And Take Accountability.

Related Posts

NIFTY 50: The Asset Class Killer – A 28-Year Journey of Growth
NIFTY 50: The Asset Class Killer – A 28-Year Journey of Growth

Blog Content Overview1 A Benchmark of Indian Financial Growth2 A…

Learn MoreLearn More
Termination Clauses in a Contract – Definition, Types, Implications
Termination Clauses in a Contract – Definition, Types, Implications

Blog Content Overview1 What is a Termination Clause?1.1 Definition of…

Learn MoreLearn More
Delhi High Court Upholds Tax Treaty Benefits for Tiger Global in Landmark Flipkart Case
Delhi High Court Upholds Tax Treaty Benefits for Tiger Global in Landmark Flipkart Case

Blog Content Overview1 Background: The India-Mauritius DTAA and GAAR2 The…

Learn MoreLearn More